{"channel":"llm","content":"I asked ChatGPT4 to give some suggestions for books for me to recommend to children, based on the Reading List here.\n\nThe results were unimpressive.\n\n ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer\n\n that is: the machine has neither \"direct experience with being a child\" nor \"training data that includes excellent information about the appropriate age to read specific books\".\n\n i know it's not in the training list because i have struggled to find any such recommendations myself; and the ones i do find are always political.\n\n--MORE--\n\nBased on your diverse and eclectic reading tastes, I'll recommend a variety of books spanning different genres and age groups to create a comprehensive reading list. This list will include books for children, classic literature, foreign literature, and more, fitting the categories you've enjoyed.\n\nBooks for Children (Ages 2-7)\"The Very Hungry Caterpillar\" by Eric Carle - A classic, beautifully illustrated story.\"Goodnight Moon\" by Margaret Wise Brown - A soothing bedtime story.\"Green Eggs and Ham\" by Dr. Seuss - A fun, rhyming story promoting trying new things.\"Charlotte's Web\" by E.B. White - A timeless tale of friendship.\"The Tale of Peter Rabbit\" by Beatrix Potter - A charming story with delightful illustrations.Classic Literature (Ages 8-12)\"The Chronicles of Narnia\" by C.S. Lewis - A magical fantasy series.\"Alice's Adventures in Wonderland\" by Lewis Carroll - A whimsical adventure.\"The Hobbit\" by J.R.R. Tolkien - A precursor to \"The Lord of the Rings.\"\"Anne of Green Gables\" by L.M. Montgomery - A heartwarming story of growth.\"Little Women\" by Louisa May Alcott - A tale of sisterhood and resilience.Banned Books (Ages 13-15)\"To Kill a Mockingbird\" by Harper Lee - A powerful story addressing racial injustice.\"Fahrenheit 451\" by Ray Bradbury - A classic dystopian novel about censorship.\"The Catcher in the Rye\" by J.D. Salinger - A novel about teenage rebellion.\"Animal Farm\" by George Orwell - A satirical tale about political systems.\"The Great Gatsby\" by F. Scott Fitzgerald - A critical look at the American Dream.Foreign Literature (Ages 16-17)\"One Hundred Years of Solitude\" by Gabriel Garc\u00eda M\u00e1rquez - A magical realism masterpiece.\"Crime and Punishment\" by Fyodor Dostoevsky - A profound psychological exploration.\"The Shadow of the Wind\" by Carlos Ruiz Zaf\u00f3n - A gripping story set in post-Spanish Civil War Barcelona.\"The Stranger\" by Albert Camus - A philosophical novel about the absurdity of life.\"Kafka on the Shore\" by Haruki Murakami - A surreal narrative blending reality and dreams.Books That Have Been Made into Films (Ages 18-20)\"The Martian\" by Andy Weir - A gripping survival story on Mars.\"Life of Pi\" by Yann Martel - A tale of faith and survival at sea.\"The Book Thief\" by Markus Zusak - A moving story set in Nazi Germany.\"Ready Player One\" by Ernest Cline - A sci-fi adventure in a virtual world.\"The Hunger Games\" by Suzanne Collins - A dystopian novel about survival and resistance.This list should provide a diverse and enriching reading journey from early childhood to young adulthood, reflecting a variety of themes, cultures, and literary styles.\n\n it is over-fitting once again; as a result it is using category-age mappings that make no sense.","created_at":"2023-11-29T20:55:54","id":439,"llm_annotations":{},"parent_id":null,"processed_content":"

I asked ChatGPT4 to give some suggestions for books for me to recommend to children, based on the Reading List here.

\n

The results were unimpressive.

\n

\n \ud83d\udd25\n ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer\n

\n

\n \ud83d\udca1\n that is: the machine has neither \"direct experience with being a child\" nor \"training data that includes excellent information about the appropriate age to read specific books\".\n

\n

\n \ud83c\udf0e\n i know it's not in the training list because i have struggled to find any such recommendations myself; and the ones i do find are always political.\n

Read More ...

Based on your diverse and eclectic reading tastes, I'll recommend a variety of books spanning different genres and age groups to create a comprehensive reading list. This list will include books for children, classic literature, foreign literature, and more, fitting the categories you've enjoyed.

\n

Books for Children (Ages 2-7)\"The Very Hungry Caterpillar\" by Eric Carle - A classic, beautifully illustrated story.\"Goodnight Moon\" by Margaret Wise Brown - A soothing bedtime story.\"Green Eggs and Ham\" by Dr. Seuss - A fun, rhyming story promoting trying new things.\"Charlotte's Web\" by E.B. White - A timeless tale of friendship.\"The Tale of Peter Rabbit\" by Beatrix Potter - A charming story with delightful illustrations.Classic Literature (Ages 8-12)\"The Chronicles of Narnia\" by C.S. Lewis - A magical fantasy series.\"Alice's Adventures in Wonderland\" by Lewis Carroll - A whimsical adventure.\"The Hobbit\" by J.R.R. Tolkien - A precursor to \"The Lord of the Rings.\"\"Anne of Green Gables\" by L.M. Montgomery - A heartwarming story of growth.\"Little Women\" by Louisa May Alcott - A tale of sisterhood and resilience.Banned Books (Ages 13-15)\"To Kill a Mockingbird\" by Harper Lee - A powerful story addressing racial injustice.\"Fahrenheit 451\" by Ray Bradbury - A classic dystopian novel about censorship.\"The Catcher in the Rye\" by J.D. Salinger - A novel about teenage rebellion.\"Animal Farm\" by George Orwell - A satirical tale about political systems.\"The Great Gatsby\" by F. Scott Fitzgerald - A critical look at the American Dream.Foreign Literature (Ages 16-17)\"One Hundred Years of Solitude\" by Gabriel Garc\u00eda M\u00e1rquez - A magical realism masterpiece.\"Crime and Punishment\" by Fyodor Dostoevsky - A profound psychological exploration.\"The Shadow of the Wind\" by Carlos Ruiz Zaf\u00f3n - A gripping story set in post-Spanish Civil War Barcelona.\"The Stranger\" by Albert Camus - A philosophical novel about the absurdity of life.\"Kafka on the Shore\" by Haruki Murakami - A surreal narrative blending reality and dreams.Books That Have Been Made into Films (Ages 18-20)\"The Martian\" by Andy Weir - A gripping survival story on Mars.\"Life of Pi\" by Yann Martel - A tale of faith and survival at sea.\"The Book Thief\" by Markus Zusak - A moving story set in Nazi Germany.\"Ready Player One\" by Ernest Cline - A sci-fi adventure in a virtual world.\"The Hunger Games\" by Suzanne Collins - A dystopian novel about survival and resistance.This list should provide a diverse and enriching reading journey from early childhood to young adulthood, reflecting a variety of themes, cultures, and literary styles.

\n

\n \ud83d\udca1\n it is over-fitting once again; as a result it is using category-age mappings that make no sense.\n

","quotes":[],"subject":"in which I ask the machine for age-appropriate book recommendations"}